The Bill Simmons Podcast
Hello Cleveland, Week 4 NFL Picks, NBA Award Leans, Raiders Realities, and Boston Despair With Joe House, Tom Pelissero, and Bill’s dad
Bill Simmons and Joe House break down a wild Week 4 NFL slate and the Aces-Fever WNBA Finals before Tom Pelissero dissects six roster moves and Bill's dad joins for Red Sox fallout, though the transcript cuts off mid-discussion on Craig Breslow's extension.
Key takeaways
- The Browns looked legitimately competent in beating Pittsburgh on Thursday night, with Deshaun Watson playing with confidence and instinct for the first time in years under offensive coordinator Todd Monken. Simmons credited Monken's scheme and a revamped offensive line for unlocking both Watson and rookie Quinshon Judkins, while House still wants to see it sustained before trusting the Browns as a real playoff threat.
- The Aces beat the Fever in a tense elimination game decided by free-throw trips and late-game execution, with A'ja Wilson scoring 36 points and going 12-for-15 from the line. House and Simmons agreed the Fever's guards (Clark and Mitchell combined 6-for-23 from three) couldn't convert in crunch time, extending Caitlin Clark's championship drought while renewing frustration over inconsistent officiating and a sideline incident between a fan and Wilson.
- Tom Pelissero detailed the Cowboys' aggressive rebuild of their defense through trades, including sending a 2028 second-round pick to Pittsburgh for cornerback Joey Porter Jr., who used a lingering "back injury" as leverage once the season started—a tactic Pelissero traced to agent David Mulugheta, who also represented Jalen Ramsey and Micah Parsons during similar standoffs.
- The Vikings traded JJ McCarthy to the Giants for a fifth-round pick, a deal Pelissero called fair value given recent backup-quarterback trades (Mac Jones for a sixth, Justin Fields for a fifth). He sees Minnesota moving on cleanly behind Carson Wentz while New York bets McCarthy's mobility fits a scheme similar to Jackson Dart's.
- Jaden Daniels is already practicing after a gruesome elbow injury and could play as soon as Week 5, wearing a large brace rather than opting for season-ending surgery. Pelissero noted Washington's offense looked sharp even with backup Marcus Mariota, crediting first-time play-callers David Blough and Durante Jones for strong in-game adjustments.
- Pelissero diagnosed the Patriots' collapse around Drake Maye as a confidence problem rather than a scheme or personnel issue, pointing to a late-season interception against Seattle where Maye forced a pass across his body instead of taking a simple checkdown. Losing AJ Brown (eligible back Week 6) and tight end Tyler Raritan compounded the disjointed offense, though Pelissero argued the underlying numbers (explosive plays, drives past midfield) suggest the Patriots are closer to turning it around than the record shows.
Notable moments
- Simmons on the Eagles' decline: "Through three weeks, 24th in the NFL in defensive pressure rate... that doesn't sound like them."
- House pitching Bills minus-one in a teaser: "I think this game will be rock bottom for the Pats."
- Simmons and House riffing on Joel Embiid: "Embiid said LeBron came to Philly to help him win a title... he's so sweet that he believes that."
- On the Aces-Fever sideline incident, Simmons said: "This league, over and over again, every time they're circling a great moment... they have to have some dumb shit happen."
- Pelissero's blunt scouting quote on Jalen Milroe-turned-Jaylen Daniels; correction, the AFC scout line on Kansas State's Daniels: "Jalen scares me. That guy should be a doctor by now with all the college football he's played."
- House, debating Harbaugh's fourth-and-10 decision: "Hey, Jim Harbaugh, please go eat a fat dick."
- Pelissero on the Raiders' culture shift under Clint Kubiak: "You couldn't come up with a less Raiders group... it's a very positive group of people."
The transcript provided cuts off partway through the closing Red Sox conversation with Bill's dad, so that segment's details and conclusion aren't reflected here.
Time saved: 2 hours, 20 minutes.